The year 2000 was an important one for HVS India; we grew from a team of two members to four. The year 2010 is also an important one as we have grown ten-fold in as many years. Our growth story seems to mirror that of the Indian hospitality sector.
It is only fair to assert that we had started from a very small base. The next decade will thus be even more pertinent as it helps the hospitality sector define its personality and carve its niche. As the Indian hospitality sector gears up to welcome an era of growth, there are several critical influencers or what we think of as game changers that will play a key role along the way. This article aims to touch upon the ten game changers that have facilitated the metamorphosis of the sector in the past decade and will continue to do so in the years ahead.
1. The Indian Economy
Not only is the elephant dancing today, but it's actually one of the only few circuses around. It has been a fantastic growth story for a country that in 1990 attracted only US$ 150 million of Foreign Direct Investments (FDIs), and then received US$ 4 billion in 2000 to over US$ 90 billion in just the past three years.
The millennium year of 2000 was hyped to be doomsday for the computers of the world with Y2K. Well, 2000 came and went by and as we all know the computers did not collapse; instead, Indian technology companies grew considerably and allowed the emergence of the BPO and KPO sectors. This led to a rising middle class and an ever-growing service sector. The opening of the telecom sector a few years earlier also had its role to play. From the most expensive to the least expensive telephone systems in the world – the Indian telecom story is certainly one for the books.
India's GDP has grown at an impressive 8.5% during the six years spanning 2003/04-2008/09. The recent global financial crisis has only reduced the rate by 2-3 percentage points and even then the economy continues to grow at the annual rate of 6% following the three quarters after the meltdown. Several domestic and global agencies have recently applauded the Indian economy's resilience and have projected a growth rate of 7% in 2010 and 7.5% for 2011. India reduced its central fiscal deficit from 8% of the GDP in the early 1990s to 2.5% in early 2008. This gave the government ample breathing space to increase its expenditure (the deficit subsequently rose to 7% of the GDP), and boost demand in the country which enabled the economy to sustain itself during the critical months of the crisis.
Additionally, the Indian demographics continue to cater to the global audience very effectively. An enormous English speaking workforce that is highly educated (more college graduates than any other nation) and ingrained in a service culture that is touted as among the best in the world, makes the Indian employee a worthwhile investment. So while our friendly red neighbour to the north has its own growth story to boast of, we believe that the Indian economy has a lot more dancing left to do before the elephant finally settles down to some silent grazing.
Key Game Changers:
- India's exponential FDI growth likely to continue
- Indian demographics, the right fit for global business audiences
- Continued growth of projected GDP, at more than 7% in the years ahead
- Resilient economy, only marginally affected by the global financial crisis
- Exponential service sector growth, with emergence of BPO, Telecom and other sectors
2. The Maturing of Indian Hotel Markets
About a decade ago, there were really only a handful of major hotel markets in India, namely the four metros and possibly a Bangalore or a Goa, a result of businesses primarily being based in and needing hotel rooms in these cities. Thus, while visitors to these major cities had a choice of several luxury and upscale hotels, affiliated with both domestic and international brands, the availability and quality of hotels declined significantly when venturing to the smaller cities.
In the last decade, as the major cities developed rapidly, real estate prices soared, and the cost of setting up and sustaining business operations in these cities became prohibitive. Companies, therefore, started looking at other cities in the country where costs were lower which resulted in the ascent of cities such as Hyderabad, Pune, Jaipur and Ahmedabad. As a result of these dynamics, there are currently about 10 to 12 main hotel markets in the country, all of which offer a variety of branded product offerings across different positionings. The emergence of these secondary and tertiary cities led to an aggressive increase in hotel development activity and provided avenues for expansion of hotel brands, which were previously dependent on new opportunities in just the five main cities.
Another trend that has now emerged in the various major markets is the growth of micro-markets, especially in the primary cities. As commutes in larger cities are increasingly measured in amount of travel time rather than distance, people are choosing to stay at hotels that are located closer to their place of work, thereby saving crucial travel time that might otherwise have been wasted in traffic. Thus, while it might have been feasible previously to build only one Holiday Inn or one Marriott in the market, the presence of independent micro-markets now allows the existence of multiple hotels with the same brand affiliation without fears of cannibalization of demand.
The Ministry of Tourism's 'Incredible India' campaign has started to strike a chord and will likely play its role in increasing visitations to India. That being said, the general sentiment is that although India has a varied bouquet of destinations to offer, relatively mediocre efforts have been made to market Brand India. The future of the Indian markets and their ability to mature into destinations relies on concerted efforts, both by the relevant government bodies and the private sector players. Creativity will be of essence and perhaps it is time to start marketing Brand India under several subsets such as cultural tourism, eco-friendly vacationing, medical tourism, religious circuits, adventure sports tourism, wildlife safaris, beach destinations and wellness vacations.
Additional influences that attract or deter foreign tourists and thus need to be addressed are the quality of infrastructure-related developments, ease of attaining a tourist visa for India, perhaps offering a visa on arrival option to nationals of certain countries, the country's image as a safe, secure and friendly destination, amongst others. Several Southeast Asian countries serve as prime examples of leisure destinations that managed to witness exponential growth in international visitations, primarily because of a well planned and effectively executed tourism strategy. India, too, will need to set clearly defined goals and work towards increasing foreign tourist arrivals if it aims to grow into a balanced, mature tourist destination.
Key Game Changers:
- Emergence of secondary and tertiary cities
- Emergence of micro-markets
- Continued marketing of Brand India
- Continued improvement of infrastructure in Indian cities and towns
- Ease of attaining Indian visas
- Development of India's image as a safe, secure and friendly destination
- Development and marketing of niche tourism like medical tourism, religious circuits, adventure tourism etc.
3. Hotel Brand Growth in India
In the year 2000, hospitality in India was primarily dominated by the domestic players, namely Taj Group of Hotels, Oberoi Hotels & Resorts, ITC Hotels, and the government owned ITDC (The India Tourism Development Corporation Ltd) Hotels, with only a handful of international brands having a token presence in the form of marketing alliances in India. Also, while some of today's home-grown hotel chains like Leela, Bharat Hotels, Sarovar and Asian Hotels were around at that time, they were for the most part single-asset owners. There was a perception that India was a tough place for foreign companies to do business in and that a strong local presence with excellent contacts was required to be able to penetrate this market. Additionally, several businesses and consequently most international brands were more focused on fast-growing markets in the Middle East and China, which offered more opportunities for growth at that time.
The economic downturn, at the beginning of the decade, led to a paradigm shift among these businesses as they could no longer depend solely on the more mature economies and they started gauging the vast opportunities that a country like India had to offer. The fact that India was less impacted by the global downturns - one at the beginning of the decade and the other at the end of it - as compared to the rest of the world has emphatically proven the inherent strength of the Indian economy and its consumer base of over a billion people. As Indians travelled more frequently around the world, they experienced international hotel brands first-hand, as a result of which these brands enjoyed greater recognition and acceptance in India. Additionally, as international visitation to India increased, the foreign brands were better placed to attract these visitors due to their strong reservations networks around the world. With the continued growth in India's GDP, improvement in the per capita income, and increased aspirational spending, the Indian hospitality sector is expected to grow faster than most countries around the world. Most major hotel brands such as Starwood, Hilton, Marriott, Hyatt and Accor already have a growing presence in India and they have an even stronger pipeline. Additionally, the emergence of a branded budget and economy segment presents tremendous opportunities and will attract many new players to an India going forward.
Key Game Changers:
- Entry of most major international brands
- Changing perception of Indian markets as a lucrative opportunity among international brands
- Growth of the Indian middle class offering a large consumer base of more than 1 billion people
- Educated and well exposed Indian audiences, likely to accept global brands wholeheartedly
- Expected emergence of branded budget and economy hotels
4. India – The MICE Business Opportunity
In 2000, we had only 2.6 million international visitations. India played host to 5.13 million arrivals in 2009, slightly down from 5.37 in 2008, owing primarily to the contraction in the global economy. When compared to some of the other Asian countries this is still a sad story, but one with immense potential and a tremendous growth opportunity. While the state and central governments focus on 'Incredible India' to bring in tourists, we believe an equal interest needs to be adopted by them to attract and grow the MICE (Meetings, Incentive, Conventions and Exhibitions) segment as it has the potential to change the face of several upcoming Indian cities. The overall international visitations are likely to grow many fold due to MICE as it allows for the sale of several hundreds or even several thousands of room nights as opposed to the transient travellers who utilize only a few room nights at a time. Additionally, most delegates often travel before and after the event, thus adding to the overall growth of the hospitality industry.
The MICE business is a key contributor to the overall hospitality industry in several nations across the globe and has the potential to add to the overall development of India as a destination. HVS research reveals that Convention or Meetings tourism accounts for over 20% of all international arrivals worldwide. Till the late nineties, North America and Europe had dominated the conventions and conference markets. The US still holds the top spot for the highest number of meetings as a single country destination. However, several Asian countries have successfully captured a growing portion of MICE business in recent years. With the emergence of India as a key economic hotspot along with China, convention tourism has enormous possibilities in the country. India's growing strength in the Information Technology arena has prompted a few prominent international bodies to host trade shows and conventions in the country and similar prominence in bio-technology, pharmaceutical and manufacturing sectors is also expected to bring convention revenues to the country in the coming years.
India, however, remains woefully inadequate in its abilities to attract large international conventions. One of the biggest reasons continues to be the lack of world class convention centres in India. The Hyderabad International Convention Centre (HICC) is India's only branded (Novotel), large scale convention facility – something that we at HVS are very proud of as it's one of our success stories. While a few additional convention centres and large format conference facilities are in the pipeline (Bangalore and Mumbai), clearly the Indian hospitality industry needs to make several strides towards developing its MICE facilities if it has any hopes of becoming a contender for this lucrative business segment in the years ahead.
Key Game Changers:
- Growth of science and technology related industries like biotechnology and pharmaceuticals that then host large conferences
- Growth of the manufacturing sector
- Increased interest in India as a travel-worthy destination
- Successful and replicable model in HICC
- Expected emergence of dedicated convention centres in more cities
5. Hospitality Marketing Trends
Ten years ago, the marketing mantra that worked best for hotels was the creation of a brand; make it exclusive, market the experience as surreal and the customer's decision to purchase was expected to automatically follow suit. This worked at that time because there was a narrow playing field with few domestic and international hotel chains in the country. Not surprising then that in 2010, India has seen an increased supply of international and domestic hotel chains that now volley with independent hotels for market share. Moreover, consumer generated media and mobile technology had yet to hit India in 2000 where the foremost influencer for the customer in making a purchase decision was the brand. The brand was conceptualized by its custodians – the internal stakeholders – to reflect the persona of the product, which made branding a one-way stream of communication mostly. Hence, Brand 2000 was a product of the internal stakeholders accented with high flying Brand Promises which translated into the Consumer Purchase Decision of 2000.
The year 2010 is a different story as the consumer is well educated, travelled, experienced and looks beyond the gloss of the brand to the value proposition and the actual delivery of brand promises. Thus, in the Year 2010, the marketing mantras are differentiation, consistency, customer satisfaction, delivery of brand promises and customer retention. Today, Brand 2010 has evolved from a one-way communication stream to a two-way one that is more flexible and accommodates the customer's needs and wants. Hence, Brand 2010 is a product of the External Stakeholder – the needs and wants of the Customers – accented by experience led, sustainable Brand Promises which now translates into the Purchase Decision of 2010.
Today, the state of economic flux wherein each dollar spent is being analyzed, renegotiated and then minimized, the marketing dilemma of marketing spend vs. incremental revenue assumes more importance. How do marketing resources of the Indian Hospitality sector continue to build their brand and market their product successfully? Consistent delivery of a superior and differentiated product experience that offers a greater perceived value will result in the acquisition and retention of customers. The pressure on consistent delivery of brand promises is further maintained by online customer feedback which impacts the attraction quotient of the product for other prospective customers. Customers in the coming decade will want to 'Find Even Before they Seek' and the advent of social networking has given a new power to customers like none other before.
In addition, to make things just a bit harder the new technology paradigm will make customer decisions even more fickle. In this decade, the customer will make purchase decisions based on the entire experience offered, its perceived value and the consumer feedback it has received as against just the brand, brand promises and product offerings alone. The customer of the coming decade will evolve to be the real custodians of the Brand.
Key Game Changers:
- Broadening of the playing field with entry of many domestic and international hotel chains
- Well educated, travelled and experienced customer base
- Evolution of the brand from a one-way communication stream to a two-way one that accommodates customer needs and experiences
- Consistent delivery of brand promises and customer experiences
- Marketing equations changing in favour of the customer with online channels like Web 2.0 and social networking
6. Hotel Development Costs
In the past ten years most commodity prices have gone up. Development costs have always been a challenge for anyone looking to build a hotel in India. The land cost has increasingly become a significant portion of the development cost for any project, accounting for 30-50% of the total development cost, while the same equates to about 15-20% internationally. The high density of development within Indian cities and the shortage of vacant land parcels suitable for hotels had led to aggressive bidding wars among prospective buyers and forced prices upwards. With the increased pace of construction activity around the world, especially in the Middle East and China, the price of construction material such as steel and concrete increased steeply in recent years. While this was offset by sourcing furniture and fixtures from China by several recent hotel projects, the additional concern regarding the quality of Chinese goods is one that now needs to be addressed.
HVS observes that hotels built in India very often exceed the brand specifications that might exist for these brands internationally and that developers often tend to spend more money on their hotels than required. A typical mid-market business hotel in the US or Europe, thus, does not cost nearly as much to construct as it does in India.
The lengthy cumbersome process of obtaining licenses and permits and construction delays serves to increase costs even more. Given the time and expense involved in working through all these issues and finally opening a hotel, developers who managed to do so were not interested in selling their hotels or asked for prices that were far in excess of replacement cost. As we look into the next ten years, we believe that as long as asking prices remain significantly higher than the replacement cost for the product, developers and investors will choose to build rather than buy.
Typical Development Cost per Key (INR)
|Luxury||12,500,000 and above|
|Upper Upscale||8,500,000 to 12,500,000|
|Upscale||6,000,000 to 8,500,000|
|Mid Market||3,500,000 to 5,500,000|
|Budget||2,500,000 to 3,500,000|
|Economy||2,500,000 and below|
Key Game Changers:
- Likely rationalization of land costs, due to the recent economic conditions
- Increased import of material from global sources, as long as quality goods are available
- Expected rationalization of costs, with government intervention in relaxing the license process
- Expected rationalization of per key development costs, with entry of brands across all positionings
7. The Debt, Equity and Valuation Paradigms
VALUATIONS - Ten years ago, when HVS had just about entered this market, many people had passed silent smirks at the idea of a valuations-related consulting firm's presence in India. Why would anyone need valuations done? No transactions in the industry had ever taken place! Last year, HVS did more valuation-related assignments than market studies and/or feasibilities. There have been only a few big-ticket transactions in the hospitality world in recent years. The future will, however, see a lot more activity as private equity players and hospitality funds start investing in this space.
DEBT - Development of hotels in India was historically undertaken by high net worth individuals who would approach banks for debt to finance a portion of their construction cost and then raise equity through personal resources or from family and friends to cover the rest of the costs. Unlike the US or the UK, where a developer historically could obtain 75-85% of his/her construction costs in the form of debt from banks on a long-term basis (30 years), Indian banks have typically lent only upto 60% of the construction cost and that too for a much shorter duration.
Additionally, since the hospitality sector was previously considered a part of Commercial Real Estate (CRE) and was subject to the same risk exposure, the cost of such debt was high. In September 2009, new guidelines on CRE released by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), asserted that the hospitality sector would no longer be treated as a part of CRE and risk exposure would be based on the profile of the borrower and the nature of the project. These new guidelines will be especially significant for the more established hospitality players who will now benefit from a lower risk weightage and consequently, lower interest rates. While the RBI's decision is a step in the right direction, what is really required is the conferring of infrastructure status to the hospitality, which will make debt financing much cheaper and give further impetus to new hotel projects around the country.
EQUITY – Given that banks would typically only lend up to 60% of the construction cost, developers were forced to then raise equity by tapping into personal resources to cover the rest of the costs. Such a process was often an inefficient and time-consuming one, with no guarantees that the required amount could be raised eventually. The entry of Private Equity (PE) funds into India has made the task of raising equity for projects much easier, as the major players have access to significant levels of capital and have greater appetite for risk than banks. Availability of PE funds has also enabled existing hospitality players to attract investments at the company level as opposed to a project level, thus giving them the flexibility to use these funds as they deem fit. Over the next ten years, we believe that PE players will become increasingly involved within the hospitality industry and look at opportunities at all market positions, especially in the budget and mid market level. While the Indian hotel industry has not seen much transaction activity in the last decade, the next ten years will bear witness to a larger number of transactions, especially in the form of mergers and acquisitions, as companies take advantage of the lower costs of debt and easier access to equity capital.
Key Game Changers:
- Expected rise in valuations and sale / purchase of hospitality assets
- Strong likelihood of infrastructure status for hospitality
- Increased possibility of securing debt at reasonable rates and for extended periods
- Growth of private equity investments and hospitality funds
- Expected rationalization of asking price of hotel assets
8. Food & Beverage (F&B) Concepts
Ten years ago, when one talked about 'eating out' at a standalone restaurant, for the most part it meant going to Kwality, Gaylords or Nirulas. Today, F&B offerings in India have evolved and are fast making a mark for themselves in the global F&B arena, too.
Until recently, five-star hotel restaurants were considered the epitome of fine dining experiences in the country; however, the rapid growth in standalone restaurants is seriously challenging the former for top honours. With a well travelled upwardly mobile consumer, new and trendy food concepts are a rage in the Indian F&B business. Of late standalone restaurants like Indigo, Tote, Olives, Tetsuma, Trishna, Zest, Smoke House Grill, to name a few have raised the bar for the F&B offerings across major metros; each outlet has a unique selling proposition (USP) that has become its claim to fame. However, the concept of standalone restaurants is still in a nascent stage and will benefit immensely if provided the right impetus with regards to ease of acquiring licenses, clearances etc. Standalone restaurants, historically, have been funded by the owning families or by a group of individuals; however, with the entry of restaurant-focused funds, we can expect heightened activity in the standalone restaurant space. All in all, we can rest assure that the Indian F&B industry is in for some exciting and great times ahead. Another aspect of the Indian F&B industry that has witnessed a radical change over the years is the design element. With more emphasis being focused on the aesthetics of the place, the touch and feel aspect is becoming of foremost importance. Restaurant design over the years has evolved from just a touch and feel of the cuisine at offer, but is now focusing on creating an impression which will remain with the customer and will act as product differentiator in the times to come. The element of WOW, and creation of an experience are key focus areas for contemporary restaurant designers. Over the recent years a host of international design firms like Super Potatoes, MIAJA, TID etc. have already put their designs to test in the local arena. A few interesting trends in restaurant design include kitchens moving into restaurants, gigantic wine display walls, bar areas as a focal point, private dining areas and the heightened use of colours and lighting.
Key Game Changers:
- Rapid growth of standalone restaurants
- Well-travelled customer open to fine dining experiences
- Entry of restaurant-focused funds
- Focus on Interior design, a priority for restaurants
9. Manpower - The Human Element
In the year 2000, Human Resource Managers were gearing up to recruit large numbers of manpower for the ambitious expansion plans that hotel companies had envisioned, post the opening up of the Indian economy. Additionally, managers were also beginning to experience the occurrence of attrition, an event that had been relatively low in frequency in the past.
With the opening of the Indian economy, several international companies rushed to establish their base in India. They, however, soon realized that their plans would need to be supplemented by effective and expressive liaisons that were somehow not available in bulk in the market. This created a spate of high-salaried job profiles whose primary function was identical to those of the employees within the hospitality industry – service. It was, hence, only natural that hotels saw an increased number of resignations from team members that were digressing from their core competencies to join high-paying jobs in call centres, banks and airlines. Several hoteliers even explored their chances with real-estate firms and infrastructure companies in the then burgeoning Dubai, and the Emirates.
The year 2010 is a sea change in these phenomena. The hard-hitting economic recession has forced several of these poaching multinational companies to relook at their staffing requirements and downsize their current teams. This has resulted in the availability of employees who are now being absorbed into the resurgent hospitality sector.
The year and the decade ahead are also expected to see oversimplification of job roles. With the advent of new types of accommodation products and need for standardization, hotel companies have considered preparing manuals detailing the procedural handling of every conceivable situation in a hotel operation scenario, thus reducing the reliance on age and experience. This has resulted in younger individuals taking on the helm of operations for a unit. Past HVS Surveys show that the average age of a Unit General Manager has dropped from 45-50 years to 30-35 years. The reduction in age profiles is prominently visible across all positions of the hotel hierarchy.
The evergreen area of concern – availability of sufficient number of staff – has also seen a change with the requirement now being changed to “availability of sufficient number of trained and qualified staff”. Hotel managers have realized the difference in service levels achieved through trained staff and otherwise and have made a transition for the better. This has created a specific requirement that is currently not being catered to by most of the educational institutions across the country.
Key Game Changers:
- Continued good-quality talent crunch
- Increasing growth opportunities for the global Indian to relocate to India
- Continued hiring from and attrition to related service sectors
- Expected offerings of Employee Stock Options and Competitive Healthcare plans by more hotel chains
- Innovative solutions to the continued challenge of attracting and retaining trained employees
10. Technology & Hospitality
Ten years ago, the most popular way of planning a trip was to visit a travel agency to get your itinerary made. Besides direct hotel reservations, the Central Reservation Systems (CRS) and Global Distribution Systems (GDS) thus served as the primary channels of sales for hotel room nights.
The growth of the internet since then has played a key role in truly globalizing the sales efforts as well as the marketing opportunities for the hotel industry. The advent of third party travel websites such as Hotels.com, Expedia.com and Travelocity.com as well as a few home grown websites like Makemytrip.com and Yatra.com has also been witnessed in recent years. These channels of distributions quickly gained strength and their contribution to the overall pie of reservations has been growing with every passing year. Additionally, independent hospitality review and opinion websites like Tripadvisor are also very popular with the travelling population of today. While these websites offer the tech-savvy traveller the opportunity to see pictures and read actual guest comments about almost every hotel in every major and minor city of India, they also offer the hotels an opportunity to showcase their products and services to a mass audience.
The future of online marketing is now one of consolidation. Hotel brands recognize the strength of the internet as a medium of sales and are increasingly working towards making their Brand.com websites user friendly. Several brands have launched 'Best Rate Guarantee' programmes that promise the consumer the best available online rate on their brand.com website as opposed to the third party online vendor. Seamless integration of Brand.com websites with the latest Property Management Systems (PM Systems) enables better yield management and pricing strategies as well. Companies like HVS also jumped onto the bandwagon and our Web Strategies division has grown faster than any of our other verticals in recent months. This relationship between technology and hospitality will only grow stronger in the years ahead.
Key Game Changers:
- Continued significant contribution of third party travel websites to hotel reservations
- Increasing role of Brand.com sites in the overall sales and marketing strategy of all hotel brands
- Increasing reliance on search engine optimization, web advertising and e-marketing
India – known the world over as the land of hospitality – is today in the defining stages of the business of hospitality. While the possibilities for growth are immense, it will take an earnest effort, both from the industry's key stakeholders in the private sector and the relevant government bodies to truly change the Indian hospitality's landscape in the years ahead. Perhaps, the industry is in need of a champion who will work towards the several reforms and ideas discussed in this article with the same zeal and enthusiasm as is characteristic of our industry's service culture. The ten influencers discussed in this article are but a drop in the ocean. Hospitality India has come a long way since 2000; however, it has a steep climb ahead and HVS looks forward to being an integral part of this journey.
About Achin Khanna
About Manav Thadani
Office. He went on to start the India operations in 1997 and was HVS' first employee in Asia. Over the last 20 years, HVS India has expanded into multiple verticals including Strategic Consulting, Executive Search, Marketing Communications, Energy & Sustainability and Professional Skills Development. In his current role, Manav oversees all eight offices across Asia Pacific, ensuring that they operate cohesively and effectively. Additionally, he runs four conferences in the region – Hotel Investment Conference - South Asia (HICSA); Hotel operations Summit India (HOSI); Tourism, Hotel Investment & Networking Conference (THINC) Indonesia, and Tourism, Hotel Investment & Networking Conference (THINC) Sri Lanka. Manav was recently the Chairman of the World Travel & Tourism Council - India Initiative (WTTCII). Contact Manav at firstname.lastname@example.org